I really like the first one!
My thoughts too.....!!!! This design seems to have something missing-the lines and the roses (former gave it great dynamics and contrasted with the curves coast/sky effect and the roses added something-and maybe on trend, Cath Kidson style????)
I agree with Chris and Something Gorgeous. I liked the linear aspect of the last design. Tried to write a more detailed response a few days ago but then it wouldn't post for some reason.